In this article

A feature has a history as well as a position

Consider an examiner working on a partial fingermark. During Analysis, they annotate a ridge ending near a blurred edge. After opening the reference print, they record a nearby bifurcation and explain that the clearer reference helped them interpret the ridge path. A final diagram might show both features without explaining which observation preceded the comparison.

This is a hypothetical example. The question it raises is practical: what did the earlier record contain, what information became available later, and how did the documented interpretation develop? The final arrangement of marks cannot answer those questions by itself.

There is a further distinction. A feature first recorded during Comparison may have been noticed earlier without being annotated. Recording time gives us an observable event in the examination. It does not establish the moment at which an examiner first perceived a feature.

What the white-box study preserved

Ulery and colleagues investigated changes between Analysis and Comparison by retaining both sets of markup. Their study involved 170 volunteer examiners, each assigned 22 pairs from a pool of 320. The feature-change analysis covered 2,957 comparisons of 313 image pairs after the stated exclusions. The retained stages made additions, deletions and changes in position available for direct examination.[1]

Changes were common. Added or deleted minutiae appeared in 90.3% of individualization determinations. Among minutiae marked as corresponding, 20% had been added during Comparison. These are different measures: one concerns the proportion of determinations involving a change; the other concerns the features selected as corresponding.[1]

Even the definition of a moved feature required a rule. The researchers treated an earlier mark that was deleted and replaced within 0.5 mm as moved. A replacement outside that tolerance became a deletion and an addition. A retained record enables this analysis, but the matching rule remains a research choice that needs justification.[1]

The material explored boundaries of sufficiency, and some participants were unfamiliar with the tools and instructions. Those conditions matter when interpreting the frequency of changes. The findings describe this study rather than a universal rate for routine casework.[1]

A change needs interpretation

A revision can reflect legitimate examination development. Seeing the reference may help an examiner follow an uncertain ridge path or place a feature more precisely. It may also reveal that the initial Analysis was incomplete, or raise concern that the reference has unduly shaped interpretation of the mark. The presence of a change does not decide between those explanations.[1]

The study’s sole false individualization involved extreme changes in markup. However, extensive changes also occurred in correct individualizations. The authors therefore cautioned that such changes were not sensitive or specific predictors of erroneous individualizations. An unusual trajectory warrants inspection of its basis; it is not an error diagnosis.[1]

Langenburg and Champod’s GYRO approach makes timing part of the annotation. Orange identifies a feature observed during Comparison using the exemplar, rather than during the initial Analysis. The purpose is to make that distinction visible to a reviewer, including when the feature contributes to the eventual opinion.[2]

How PROFAS preserves the earlier basis

The white-box work, GYRO and the NIST human-factors work were among the research foundations of PROFAS. I began building it in 2017 with an interest in preserving the examination behind the answer. The timing of observations matters because the information available to the examiner changes as the work proceeds.

In the current workflow, submitting Analysis fixes its accepted records before the designated reference can be explicitly opened. Opening the reference is a separate recorded action. Later Comparison contributions have their own place in the sequence, while the submitted Analysis remains available as the earlier basis.

Earlier-stage observations are frozen. A later contribution can explain a changed interpretation and add Comparison observations; it does not overwrite an Analysis feature. Amending the earlier work requires a reasoned successor examination that preserves the original submission. This distinction helps a reader separate the first account from the later account.

For an authorised researcher, replay reconstructs accepted records at a selected point within an exact submitted basis. It can show which accepted contributions were present and whether reference opening had occurred. It reconstructs recorded work, including available recorded views, rather than every visual movement or unrecorded thought.

The examination record gives accepted contributions a sequence. Read later Comparison observations alongside the fixed Analysis basis rather than treating the final display as the whole history.

Information arrives in a sequence

The NIST human-factors report recommends specifically documenting modifications made after comparison has begun. It places that recommendation alongside the need for contemporaneous material sufficient for another examiner to assess the initial interpretation. The timing and substance of a change belong together.[3]

The later LSU-E framework extends attention to the sequence of information more broadly. Dror and Kukucka argue that experts should document the information encountered and changes in their opinions as the sequence develops. Encountered during the current PROFAS project, this work adds a broader information-management framework to the original concern with retaining observations before and after comparison.[4]

Software can record designated reference opening within its workflow. An examiner may also have prior familiarity or receive information elsewhere. Study instructions and exposure records therefore remain important when interpreting a sequence. An opening event establishes a recorded access boundary, not proof of attention or freedom from every other influence.

Questions for the next study

A study can ask which observations were recorded before reference exposure, which were contributed later, and how those contributions relate to clarity, difficulty and opinion. It can investigate the explanations accompanying changed interpretations rather than reducing development to a single count.

Such work needs explicit definitions and attention to the recording process itself. Instructions may influence what participants choose to annotate. The aim is to preserve enough of the sequence to study that process and let another person inspect it. A useful record makes change understandable without presuming what the change means.

FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE

Sources & further reading

The original research behind this article.

  1. Ulery, B. T., Hicklin, R. A., Roberts, M. A., and Buscaglia, J. (2015). Changes in latent fingerprint examiners’ markup between analysis and comparison. Forensic Science International, 247, 54–61.(opens in a new tab) Back to the article
  2. Langenburg, G., and Champod, C. (2011). The GYRO system—A recommended approach to more transparent documentation. Journal of Forensic Identification, 61(4), 373–384.(opens in a new tab)

    The source available for this article is the authors’ retained 2010 draft.

    Back to the article
  3. Expert Working Group on Human Factors in Latent Print Analysis (2012). Latent Print Examination and Human Factors: Improving the Practice through a Systems Approach. NISTIR 7842. NIST and NIJ.(opens in a new tab) Back to the article
  4. Dror, I. E., and Kukucka, J. (2021). Linear Sequential Unmasking–Expanded (LSU-E): A general approach for improving decision making as well as minimizing noise and bias. Forensic Science International: Synergy, 3, 100161.(opens in a new tab) Back to the article