RESEARCH INTO PRACTICE / Education and experience
Building experience through sustained forensic practice
An exercise becomes more useful when the student’s first examination, the feedback and the later response remain available for discussion. A programme of practice should also test what transfers beyond the familiar example.
In this article
Can the student use the learning elsewhere?
A student returns to a fingerprint pair after a teaching session. They can now find the feature the tutor discussed and explain the expected answer. That is a useful step. The educational question is what happens when the next impression has a different appearance, the relevant feature is less clear, or the first plausible interpretation is misleading.
Repeated success on a familiar example can mix several achievements: remembering the answer, recognising a previously highlighted feature and learning a method that transfers. A practical programme needs opportunities for all three, while its assessment should distinguish them. Completing more exercises does not by itself demonstrate greater competence.
For PROFAS, this raises a design question about the student record. Can an educator inspect what the student contributed before feedback, discuss the particular source detail behind that feedback and compare the later account? Retaining those contributions creates material for teaching and evaluation; the learning benefit still needs to be investigated.
Training benefits have a particular task and test
Searston and Tangen’s 2017 experiment involved 100 undergraduate fingerprint novices and tested them on fifty novel pairs after training. Corrective feedback, pair labels accompanied by learner-generated descriptions, and contrasting examples each produced better discrimination than the baseline training condition. In the labels condition, pairs were identified as “Match” or “No Match” and learners described their similarities and differences. The test used previously unseen prints, so its results addressed transfer beyond recognition of the training images.[1]
The pattern of benefit matters. Improvements were concentrated on highly similar non-matching pairs, and comparisons between the three enhanced training conditions were not statistically significant. The study therefore supports a more specific claim than “feedback is always best” or “more practice improves every kind of fingerprint decision”.[1]
Growns and colleagues’ 2022 work adds newer evidence for statistical feature training with novices and professional fingerprint examiners. It also describes limits arising from its stimulus database and the visibility of the trained features. This work, encountered during the current project, helps frame further teaching research. It does not establish that using PROFAS produces those training effects.[2]
Feedback, revisiting and contrast have different roles
Dunlosky and colleagues’ review of learning techniques gives strong general support to practice testing and distributed practice. Corrective feedback can repair errors made during retrieval, and testing with feedback generally outperformed testing alone in the evidence they reviewed. Trying to produce an answer before consulting it differs from repeatedly reading the supplied explanation.[3]
A forensic examination is more complex than a recall question. Students must select and interpret source detail, explain uncertainties and develop an evaluation. The general learning evidence gives reasons to study active attempts, correction and return visits in this setting; it does not specify a validated schedule for acquiring forensic competence.[3]
Spacing and interleaving also deserve separate consideration. Birnbaum and colleagues’ category-learning experiments show how juxtaposing different categories can support discrimination, while an unrelated delay can interrupt that comparison. A programme might revisit a skill over time and deliberately contrast confusable examples, but these are different instructional choices. Their results are general learning evidence, rather than a test of forensic students using PROFAS.[4]
Give the first attempt and feedback their own basis
In PROFAS, an educator can define an exercise with learning objectives, a rubric and assigned material. Students record their own observations and evaluation. The workflow requires submission of the independent first attempt before the student can open released feedback. That preserves an account of what was contributed before access to the exercise’s feedback.
Educator feedback is attached to an exact submitted attempt. It can discuss the observation, explanation or limitation in that work while retaining the submitted source basis. A configured reference answer also has a fixed submitted basis, checked against the exercise material and protocol. Release and actual opening are separate recorded steps.
Later work can remain linked to the earlier examination. This makes it possible to discuss a changed interpretation without replacing the original contribution. The useful teaching question is then concrete: what changed after this feedback, what remained unresolved and how did the student explain the change? The record cannot establish what the student privately understood or encountered elsewhere.
A portfolio is an educational proposal
One intended use is a portfolio developed across a three-year forensic science programme. Early exercises might focus on description and uncertainty; later work could ask students to justify comparisons, consider alternatives and explain limitations with increasing independence. Selected returns to earlier material could sit alongside new exercises that test transfer.
Such a portfolio would require curriculum design, educator time, suitable materials and an assessment approach agreed by the university. The existing workflow supplies independent attempts, controlled feedback access and linked later work. It does not supply an adaptive teaching algorithm, an automatic spaced-repetition scheduler or a validated three-year course.
This learning literature helps sharpen the educational proposal: distinguish immediate task performance from durable learning, choose comparison conditions deliberately and state which outcomes the programme aims to improve.
Evaluate what lasts and what transfers
A useful teaching study would assess students after a delay and on unfamiliar material. It could examine practical comparison performance, the quality of documentation, the handling of uncertainty and the explanation of alternatives. Where the task permits, measures should also distinguish discrimination from a changed tendency to give one answer. These are proposed study outcomes, not demonstrated platform benefits.
The design should separate prior experience, feedback exposure and repeated material from first encounters. Educator judgements need a stated rubric and review basis, and confidence or satisfaction should be considered alongside performance. A growing portfolio can show the work completed; it needs an appropriate assessment design before it can support a claim about competence.
The opportunity is a sustained practical conversation with the student’s examination available to inspect. An educator can ask why a feature was selected, what supported a comparison and how feedback affected the next account. PROFAS aims to make that conversation better informed, while leaving its educational effectiveness open to careful evaluation.
FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE
Sources & further reading
The original research behind this article.
- Searston, R. A., and Tangen, J. M. (2017). Training perceptual experts: Feedback, labels, and contrasts. Canadian Journal of Experimental Psychology, 71(1), 32-39.(opens in a new tab) Back to the article
- Growns, B., Towler, A., Dunn, J. D., Salerno, J. M., Schweitzer, N. J., and Dror, I. E. (2022). Statistical feature training improves fingerprint-matching accuracy in novices and professional fingerprint examiners. Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications, 7, 60.(opens in a new tab) Back to the article
- Dunlosky, J., Rawson, K. A., Marsh, E. J., Nathan, M. J., and Willingham, D. T. (2013). Improving Students’ Learning With Effective Learning Techniques: Promising Directions From Cognitive and Educational Psychology. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 14(1), 4–58.(opens in a new tab) Back to the article
- Birnbaum, M. S., Kornell, N., Bjork, E. L., and Bjork, R. A. (2013). Why interleaving enhances inductive learning: The roles of discrimination and retrieval. Memory & Cognition, 41, 392–402.(opens in a new tab) Back to the article